For over 20 years, Water Street Coffee has been home to a very delicious and popular sweet treat — our handmade Incredible Bars! They are wonderful, natural peanut butter and graham cracker bars, covered with melted dark chocolate and a white chocolate drizzle.

Rich in History

You may not know that the Incredible Bar is not only a Water Street recipe, but a family recipe. Throughout the years, you have enjoyed the exact recipe from Jan Smutek—the mother of Water Street Coffee owner, Mark. As a mother of three, Jan had an arsenal of family-favorite recipes. The Incredible Bar was just too good not to share! So, with her blessing, it became one of Water Street Coffee’s very first dessert offerings.

An Incredible Treat Reimagined

Recently, our team came together to develop a new and fun way to enjoy this beloved snack. With convenience and snacking at home in mind, INCREDIBLE BAR MINIS were born! This 8 oz. jar contains yummy, frozen, bit-sized versions of the treat you know and love.

Did you say frozen? Yes! We have consumed many, MANY Incredible Bars over the years and couldn’t get over how delicious they are frozen! The best part is, with their resealable jar, you can have one or two individual bites, twist the lid back on and enjoy the rest later. Of course, you are welcome to thaw them in the fridge and snack on them chilled. Just keep in mind the shelf life decreases and you will have to eat them sooner.

Supporting New Families

Mark’s mother, Jan, was not only the reason we have this longstanding Water Street treat, she is also the inspiration for our newest giving endeavor. Jan spent many years volunteering at a local Detroit children’s hospital in the pediatric unit. In her honor, Water Street Coffee is donating 1% of our Incredible Bar Mini sales to the Bronson Hospital Mother/Baby Unit.

That’s right! When you purchase our Incredible Bar Minis you are helping to give towards this cause. Do you know someone who loves a good chocolate, peanut buttery treat? Buy an extra container to give to them! Or buy some extra containers for yourself.


How to place a Special Order

Would you like to order a large quantity of an item we carry in the store? We can do that! Any of our current food, desserts, baked goods and syrups can be ordered from our very own Water Street Kitchen and picked up from a Water Street Café.

Steps to order:

  1. View our current menu.
  2. Call our Kitchen at (269) 373-6904.
  3. Place your order and choose a Water Street Café to pick up your items.
    **Give at least a 48-hour notice**
  4. Pick up and pay for your order at your desired café.

Food Quantities and Prices

Below are just a few examples of the items that are available from our current menu. Be sure to ask our kitchen what other food and pricing is available.


Can I purchase a bottle of your Vanilla Syrup? Yes! Any of our current syrups are available to order.

Do you deliver to my event? No, your order must be picked up and paid for at a Water Street Café.

Can I order a full cake or pie? No, we currently do not offer full cakes or pies as a part of this service.

Can I order a large amount of scones for my meeting? Yes! Any baked good that is currently on the menu can be ordered.

Do you offer hot chocolate for a large group? No, however, you are welcome to purchase our Sleeping Bear Hot Chocolate or our Cocoa Del Sol Chocolate and use our Slow Cooker Hot Chocolate Recipe to make a large batch of our hot chocolate.

Farmer's Market

Check out our list of local produce and farms!

Crisp Country Acres – Holland, MI

Great Lakes Potato Chips – Traverse City, MI

Harrison Pickle Company – Kalamazoo, MI

Jack and Jill’s Maple Farm – Paw Paw, MI

Michigan Egg – Kalamazoo, MI

The Old Home Place- LaGrange, IN

Silverbeet – Bangor, MI

Read more about Silverbeet!

Matcha powder, whisk, and matcha latte

Matcha, often known for its spiritual and health benefits, has a long history dating back to 9th century Japan. Once only accessible by elite, Zen practitioners and samurai warrior classes, now you can enjoy this revered drink at all of our Café locations.

Matcha as a tea or infused

Matcha is a very pleasant and soothing drink that offers complex distinctively sweet flavor, combined with earthy and rich umami notes. It can be drank as a traditional tea or added to a variety of beverages. Our Roast Master Seth shared, “A hand-crafted matcha latte is a great source of clean, healthy energy.”  Since we’ve added matcha to our menu, we love it so much, we’ve come up with a variety of matcha-infused concoctions available at our Café locations.

Matcha Latte (Hot or Iced) – Get the energy boost you need without the crash! A perfect blend of matcha tea and textured milk with a touch of sugar.

Matcha Tea – Get the clean energy boost you need for the day with this traditionally prepared stone ground matcha.

Matcha Lemonade (Seasonal) – A tart, sweet and refreshing drink combining Matcha and our House-made Lemonade.

Vanilla Matcha Shake – We take our house-made vanilla ice cream and blend it with milk and stone ground matcha for this creamy energizing treat!

What is Matcha?

A traditional Japanese green tea powder, matcha is made by stone milling Tencha leaves into a fine powder. Harvested just once a year between May and June, Tencha is grown almost exclusively to make matcha. For 3-5 weeks prior to harvest, the tea bushes are shaded using a traditional frame-and-hatch technique. This shading inhibits photosynthesis, boosting chlorophyll levels and creating a deep green leaf color. In its struggle to gather more light, the tea bush pulls nutrients from its roots and grows wide, thin, tender tea leaves. This results in boosted levels of natural plant sugars, amino acids and caffeine.

The many benefits of Matcha

Matcha is often touted for its health benefits, along with its ability to enhance mood and aid in concentration. Unlike other green teas, with matcha the whole leaf is consumed, giving it a much higher concentration of caffeine. A rare amino acid found in the leaves, L-theanine, counteracts many of the negative side effects of the caffeine, typically inhibiting the jitters or crash you may experience. Many have even shared that matcha has a relaxing and calming effect on them.

Matcha tea is packed with antioxidants, which may help to fortify the immune system and prevent disease. The leaf provides a variety of vitamins and minerals, including vitamin C, selenium, chromium, zinc and magnesium. Matcha has also been known to improve skin complexion and detoxify the body, along with a myriad of other health benefits.


At Water Street, we are always looking for new and exciting areas to expand and respond to what our customers are looking for. When the studying and work has ended for the day, we want our customers to be able to sit back, relax, and catch up with friends. What better way than with a refreshing cocktail, smooth glass of wine, or cool local beer? With that in mind, we are excited to debut our recently acquired liquor license at our Portage cafe with an official Cocktail Launch Party on June 16th, from 6pm-10pm.

It’s party time!

We’ll be offering 25% off all cocktails, beer, and wine from our Spring Menu, and 30% off delicious appetizers all evening. Guests can also enjoy live music from Borr+McFerrin from 6pm-8pm, fun giveaways, and a special tasting from One Well Brewing.

Now is your chance to try something cool and refreshing, like our Hibiscus Twist, made with Tito’s Vodka, lemon juice, freshly brewed Hibiscus Rooibos Iced Tea, and Lavender Syrup (made in house using locally grown lavender from Shades of Lavender Farm in Mattawan, MI). Looking for something with a little zip? Try our Irish Coffee with a BANG! We combine Jameson Whiskey, Water Street’s own cold brew (Iced Coffee with a BANG), and simple syrup, then we pour over coffee ice cubes and top with a float of heavy whipping cream.

With such a vibrant local beer scene in Kalamazoo and Portage, we couldn’t help but feature some local beers on our beer list. One of our favorites is One Well Brewing’s Sweet Water Street. An Imperial Porter at 7.1%, this beer highlights our very own Water Street coffee, as well as donuts from another Kalamazoo mainstay: Sweetwater’s Donut Mill. Sweet and smooth, it’s the perfect beer to pair with our summer desserts. Our beer list also features selections from Kalamazoo’s own Bell’s Brewery, as well as Grand Rapids’ Founder’s Brewing Company and Brewery Vivant, and more.

If wine is what you’re looking for, we have a carefully selected list, including a 2016 Barista Coffee Pinotage from Western Cape, South Africa. Rich with coffee, chocolate, and mulberry notes, we recommend pairing a glass with a delicious Spinach and Feta Turnover. Or try a mimosa, featuring the Valdelavia Cava Brut, along with fresh squeezed orange juice.

Water St Live!

What else goes well with a cocktail? Live music! We are happy to continue our Water St Live series of free live music at our Portage cafe throughout the summer. Catch Borr+McFerrin at our Cocktail Launch Party on June 16th, then come back to hear The Birdseed Salesmen with Helen Yee on June 28th. Our full event listing can be found on our events page, as well as on Facebook. Each of these events will be free of charge and feature local artists from the Kalamazoo or West Michigan area. With such a lively musical community in Kalamazoo and Portage, we are thrilled to be able to showcase local musicians’ talents and provide a fun, relaxing evening event.

Our cocktail, beer, and wine menu will be changing seasonally, so come in and try these offerings while you can. And we hope to see you on June 16th!

Beer and and wine is served from 7am to close Monday through Saturday, and 12pm to close on Sunday. Cocktails are served 4pm to close Monday through Friday, 7am to close Saturday, and 12pm to close Sunday. Stay tuned for news on approval of our full license, which will allow us to serve cocktails with Sunday morning brunch, as well as let guests enjoy their drinks on our outdoor patio.


Sometimes you just need an extra little something to satisfy your sweet tooth. Combining your favorite tea with the perfect treat can be a wonderful sensation for your taste buds. There are so many foods that pair well with tea, so how do you choose? Maybe we can help! Here are five of our favorite tea and dessert pairings.


Lavender honey cupcake

Craigmore English Breakfast Flowery Orange Pekoe Black tea and Lavender Honey Cupcake

The smooth Craigmore English Breakfast Flowery Orange Pekoe contains tea leaves that are left whole and include the young buds of the tea plant, also known as tips. Uncut tips hold onto all the essential oils needed for a delicate flavorful brew. This smooth tea pairs well with the mouth watering Lavender Honey Cupcake. This sweet cupcake filled with honey and local lavender comes together with the earthy notes from the tea to create a wonderful aroma. Do you like warm earthy flavors with some creamy sweetness? Then you should try this delicious pairing!



Earl Grey tea and a Toffy SconeOrganic Earl Grey Supreme Black Tea and Chocolate Toffee Scone

Our Organic Earl Grey Supreme Black Tea is a classic tea blend that is rich in flavor and pairs well with many foods. The black tea leaves are infused with fine Italian bergamot citrus oil to create this Organic Earl Grey Supreme. This black tea is perfect on its own, but you can always add milk or honey. When you are looking for something to pair with this stronger tea, you do not want to pick something that is too overpowering. That’s why our Chocolate Toffee Scone is a perfect choice. This tasty scone is full of chocolate chips and toffee bites with drizzled chocolate to top it off. The sweet chocolate and toffee flavors in the scone compliment the robust citrus ones in the tea. Love Earl Grey Tea, but don’t know what to eat with it? Try our Chocolate Toffee Scone!





Four Seasons Spring Oolong Tea and Lemon Cream CookiePerson pouring tea from a tea pot

The Four Seasons Spring Oolong Tea is admired for its long-lasting aroma. This delightful drink is crafted by oolong tea artisans and highlights the delicate notes of jasmine and lilac. This floral tea pairs well with our sweet Lemon Cream Cookie. The heavenly lemon cream cookie is made with freshly squeezed lemon juice and lemon zest baked in a creamy cookie. This sweet dessert helps emphasize the delicious tropical flavors in the Four Seasons Oolong Tea without overpowering the delicate floral notes. Next time you are looking for a pleasant fruity tea and dessert pairing, come try our Four Seasons Spring Oolong Tea with a lemon cream cookie.



Almond Biscottis in containerFair Trade Organic Jade Cloud Green Tea and Almond Biscotti

The Fair Trade Organic Jade Cloud is a bright and fresh green tea, that has been nurtured by the clouds and cool mist of early spring. This lively tea is a classically delicious green tea. The Fair Trade Organic Jade Cloud Green Tea pairs well with our Almond Biscotti. The Almond Biscotti is a crisp treat that contains almonds. Biscottis are baked twice to make them extra crisp, perfect for dunking into a cup of tea. This nutty biscotti is no exception! If you’re looking for a light mid-afternoon snack, enjoy a mild grassy green tea, and want to try something sweet and crunchy, then this is the pairing for you.







Chocolate Pretzel TriangleOrganic Peppermint Rooibos and Chocolate Pretzel Triangle

Refreshingly crisp but not overpowering, the caffeine-free Organic Peppermint Rooibos is candy-sweet with a fresh burst of peppermint. The soothing Organic Peppermint Rooibos pairs well with chocolate, specifically our Chocolate Pretzel Triangle. This tasty triangle is full of crunchy pretzel pieces and dark and white chocolate drizzled with salted caramel. Chocolate and peppermint is a popular combination; the surprising addition of salted caramel perfectly balances this sweet refreshing pairing. If you like peppermint and you like chocolate, this is one you should definitely try!



What’s your favorite tea and dessert pairings? Come stop in at any of our Water Street cafes to give them a try. Check out our menu to create your perfect pairings!

Sometimes the day just isn’t complete without a touch of something sweet. A successful marriage of dessert and drink can deliver unexpected and delicious experiences for the palate.  Here are some of our very favorite pairings of our homemade sweet treats and smooth coffee picks.  Stop by any of our Water Street cafes to give them a try. Or check out our menus to create your own perfect pairing!

Biscotti and Cappuccino 

Do breakfast the Italian way… with a crunchy biscotti, dipped in a frothy fresh cappuccino. Our biscotti, meaning twice-baked in Italian, are expertly baked in our Water Street kitchen. Our favorites include the Pistachio Chocolate Chip Biscotti and the ever popular Almond Biscotti.  Paired with the natural sweetness of the textured froth and the smooth espresso in the cappuccino, this is a combination that will leave you dreaming of the rolling hills of Tuscany!

Lemon Bars

Lemon Bar and Sumatra Mandheling

For the true coffee connoisseur, a contrast in sharp tartness with smooth earthiness is a real treat.  Water Street’s luscious lemon bars have been a staple for years, and it’s easy to taste why!  We make a rich filling with freshly squeezed lemon juice and lemon zest, then bake to perfection in a shortbread cookie crust. Balancing the delicate flavors of the lemon bar with our popular Sumatra Mandheling roast creates the perfect balanced refreshment.  Grown by the Mandheling tribe of west-central Sumatra, Indonesia, near the port of Padang, the Sumatra Mandheling has a heavy, concentrated body, very low acidity, and a rich flavor with hints of dark chocolate. From its rich, sweet aroma to its earthy finish, this brew is deliciously complex.  We love it brewed in a Chemex to bring out the full body of this coffee.


Vanilla Cheesecake and Cortado

We think cheesecake goes well with almost anything, but it especially stands out alongside the creaminess of the cortado.  We make our cortados with a 1:1 ratio of frothed milk to fresh espresso, which cuts down on the acidity.  Popular in Spain and Portugal, the cortado is commonly ordered in the afternoon, for a delicious pick-me-up.  We recommend trying a cortado with our own featured espresso, which gives you a brighter, more complex flavor. Water Street’s famous vanilla cheesecake is a dessert lover’s dream, with made-from-scratch creamy filling baked in a graham cracker crust.  Together, these two can help you solve any problem that comes your way.

Cupcake and Dolce de Leche

For the true sweet tooth, there’s nothing better than a freshly-baked cupcake and the caramely goodness of a hot Dolce de Leche. We love so many of our cupcake flavors, but we’re recently very excited about our new Margarita Salted Lime: a vanilla cupcake made with fresh lime zest, topped with vanilla frosting and a light sprinkle of sea salt.  Or for a vegan twist, try our vegan dark chocolate or orange mango cupcakes – both rich and delicious!  We mix our house-made caramel sauce with our brewed coffee and add steamed milk to create our popular Dolce de Leche drink. Topped with whipped cream and caramel drizzle, it’s a decadent dessert all by itself.  Paired with a cupcake, it’s perfection!

Silverbeet Farm is a micro-farm producing certified naturally grown herbs, vegetables and flowers. This produce provides homes, grocery stores and restaurants – like Water Street Coffee – with the freshest, most flavorful, local ingredients.

How the Farm Started

Silverbeet Farm started out of love – love for gardening, for food, for vegetables, for fresher-than-you’ll-ever-taste heirloom tomatoes. Chanterelle, along with her sister, Sureau, and friend started this beautiful 2-acre farm located in Bangor, Michigan. 

The passion that started Silverbeet Farm started with Chanterelle’s childhood. Chanterelle and Sureau grew up in a vegetarian family that grew and cooked their own food. This family ate farm to table before it was cool! Her love for fresh local food turned her into an avid gardener, which lead her to work on several farms and eventually to attend the Master Gardener Program at MSU Extension for her adult horticultural education.

Today’s Silverbeet Farm

When we caught up with her, Chanterelle pointed out that she enjoys “creating something real and needed for [her] local community.” And “real” takes on a very literal meaning when it comes to Silverbeet Farm’s food. They use organic seeds and no synthetic pesticides to raise their 800+ plants — which includes 23 varieties of tomatoes!

Silverbeet Farm supplies fresh vegetables for the farmer’s families, ingredients to local restaurants, and they also sell their beautiful flowers and vegetables at the Kalamazoo Farmers’ Market. The Kalamazoo community has embraced the Farmers’ Market, all of its vendors and the local food movement. Silverbeet Farm is happy to be a part of that growth.

A Collaboration for Quality Food

Over the years Silverbeet Farm and Water Street Coffee have developed an extremely collaborative relationship. A big contributor to that relationship is their unique connection as several Silverbeet Farm employees work in Water Street Coffee’s kitchen during the winter off-season. Chanterelle says, “this allows for a fantastic level of collaboration and open dialogue. It’s the best part of working together”.

Plus, having the inside scoop on what’s looking most delicious for the upcoming season allows the team at Water Street Coffee to further elevate the Café food offerings, which in the end makes for happier customers. As Tera, head chef at Water Street Coffee put it, “we are grateful to work with a local farm that is as passionate and excited about quality, fresh and local as we are here at Water Street Coffee.”